Good Fellas Pizzeria

First things first—this joint’s décor and upholstery? Fuggedaboutit. You walk in and bam—it’s like you just stepped into a 1920s speakeasy where everyone knows your name and nobody asks questions. The vibe is criminally good. Now let’s talk eats, see. We ordered the cauliflower crust cheese pizza with candied jalapeños (a tip from the owner’s wife—she knows things) and pineapple (yeah, yeah, pineapple on pizza… take it up with the boss). Every bite was a knockout. No witnesses. Just flavor. Then came the BBQ six-pack of wings—juicy, flavorful, and so tender the meat practically jumped off the bone on its own. These wings didn’t do time in the oven too long, if you know what I mean. We also grabbed the fried mushrooms with a cup of ranch, and let me tell ya, they disappeared faster than a guy who talks too much. This place knows how to take care of its customers—and I ain’t talkin’ about sleeping with the fishes. If you haven’t eaten here yet, I’ll do you a favor (and since it’s my daughter’s wedding, that’s a big deal): you’ll never have to eat flavorless food again. Go to Good Fellas. Sit down, eat up, and let them take care of yous… capisce?

10/10. Surpassed expectation 🙌. The sauce,cheese,sausage,pepperoni all went together perfectly. I loved the crust as well. Had to get 2 separate pizzas!! Whole family crushed these pizzas real fast. All the kids kept going on about how this was the best pizza they'd had. I couldn't believe how good the service was. Spectacular 👌treated like family. I lived in streator for over 30 years. Came back today just for the pizza. It was well worth it. I never would have imagined a place this nice in Streator. inside and outside. Nicest dine-in restaurant Streator has ever had. By a long shot. I love the true Italian feel of this place. Felt right at home!

The crust was good thin and crispy. A nice amount of cheese. The sauce could use a bit more seasoning for my taste. The sausage is advertised as,a crumble sausage but isn't. The wings were tender and sauced well. Server ( I think her name was Brooklyn) was nice and attentive.

Cheese Curds are a must try! Pizza was very good, I was a little surprised the crust seemed premade but for the price the quality was worth it!

The hostess and our server were both super sweet people! Food didn't take too long too come out and was super yummy (highly recommend the cheese curds) and the patio was beautiful to sit out on. We also briefly met the owner and he seemed like a chill guy. 10/10 :)