Vitale’s Pizza Cellar

Horrible experience, this place was not busy at all. Not only did we Wait over 1 hour for are food the food was wrong making us to wait longer and then when asking for some sort of compensation we were told no after explaining are experience with our sever. If you would like your straws thrown on your table and have to ask for refills and like to get ignored by your waiter I would recommend 100% but if not I would not recommend at all.

Went there for dinner last night. Had a 12" pepperoni, a 14" sausage, 1 Italian beef with fries, 2 sodas, and 2 coronas. Bill was $70. Looked at the menu prices and by adding them up, it was less than $55. I know that tax isn't $15 in Princeton. Also was nice enough to give a $15 tip and I have had way better service with waitresses that were given less for a tip. I am a very generous tipper when treated well by my waitresses. Very sad because I have always loved the pizza cellar. Been my favorite since I was a little kid.

It was hot but took me back to when I was a kid. Pizza is really good but my personal taste is thought the sauce is a little sweet. I loved the crust and the cheese. I like that they used real sausage chunks. Great service, good price. I'd recommend

Food was great! Had Italian beefs. Long big sandwich with A LOT of meat on it. Big cup of sauce to dip it in. Service wasn't too good however. We waited 10-15 minutes just to get noticed for them to take our order. They took it and waited a bit for the food. THEN, had to get her attention to get our check. Just glad we didn't need refills. Good thing the food was delicious

Some of these reviews are way too harsh but what would you expect from pizza experts. I don’t live in Princeton I visit and I try to support mom and Pop pizza joints. I spend most of my money on pizza here. Not Chicago Tavern pizza but I haven’t found a better pizza in the Princeton area. I like their sauce slightly sweet. If they could figure out how to make the crust a bit crisper it wouldn’t hurt them. I prefer getting served by the younger waitstaff versus the lady that owns this place.